I was also confused as to why he said to hold off on a more physical relationship with my BF then went to my BF to get him to bring this up. During the party James texted me to come outside. James came up behind me and pulled my hands away and asked the couple if they had ever seen nipples as hard as mine. As a newly 16-year-old we went to a fast-food place and that was like fine dining to me. She then started to suck on my nipple as James started to finger me under the water. He told me to get in, but I told him I didn’t have my suit. It was so humiliating to walk home with cum running out of my pussy and my hair and body sticky smelling like pee. The next day I was called over to James’s house by my BF, I was terrified, what if James came clean, what if Tommy knows more than what he’s letting on. He laughed and stopped to take a picture
